{"database": "press", "table": "releases", "rows": [["https://www.hirono.senate.gov/news/press-releases/hirono-wyden-sanders-senate-democrats-call-out-insurance-company-collaboration-with-trump-administration-to-kick-thousands-of-americans-off-health-insurance", "Hirono, Wyden, Sanders, Senate Democrats Call Out Insurance Company Collaboration with Trump Administration to Kick Thousands of Americans Off Health Insurance", "2026-10-27", "2026", "2026-10", "Democrat", "Senate", "HI", "Mazie K. Hirono", "H001042", "www.hirono.senate.gov", "hirono", "https://www.hirono.senate.gov/news/press-releases", "scraper", "WASHINGTON, D.C. \u2013 U.S. Senator Mazie K. Hirono (D-HI) joined Senate Finance Committee Ranking Member Ron Wyden (D-OR), Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee Ranking Member Bernie Sanders (I-VT), and 10 other Senate Democrats in opening an inquiry into the actions of ten health insurance companies following their decision to work with the Trump administration and to strip thousands of enrollees from their health coverage without due process.\n\n\u201cAligning with Republicans and their so-called \u2018war on fraud,\u2019 insurance companies chose to participate in a collaborative effort with the Trump administration to inject yet more chaos and damage into the ACA Marketplace,\u201d the Senators wrote. \u201cThis year, nearly 3 million people have lost coverage while millions more are paying sky-high premiums and higher deductibles for insurance that covers less.\u201d\n\nThe letters, sent to the chief executives of ten of the largest health insurance companies participating in the federal marketplace enrollment, details the troubling nature of these companies' compliance with the Trump administration\u2019s directive to strip some eligible Americans of their health coverage. The Senators note that this move was based on discredited, partisan analyses suggesting zero-dollar premium plans and zero-claims enrollees are reliable proxies for fraud.\n\nThe letter outlines how insurers took specific steps to assist the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) in this likely illegal effort by sending unsolicited communications, including in some cases asking enrollees to verify their Social Security numbers. Individuals who did not respond were deemed fraudulent and their coverage was terminated. The Senators emphasized that the companies carried out these communications months before the federal agency attempted to change its guidance to support the request, bypassing the established process for mid-year eligibility determinations.\n\n\u201cWe have many questions about the role of [insurance company] in this flawed process used to terminate coverage for 760,000 enrollees, and the judgment exercised by insurance companies that chose to cooperate with CMS officials without requesting clarification about the specific authorities being relied on to support this request or raising concerns to Congress on behalf of their customers, enrollees that your companies receive billions of dollars in premiums and taxpayer support each year to serve,\u201d the Senators continued.\n\nTo understand the full scope of this scheme and the insurers' failure to raise concerns to Congress on behalf of their customers, the Senators called on the companies to provide information such as:\n\nWhen CMS first contacted them to evaluate unauthorized enrollments and whether the agency provided a legal basis for the request.\n\nWhy the companies carried out mid-year eligibility redeterminations that conflicted with the existing federal exchange manual at the time.\n\nWhether they view zero-dollar net premiums, a lack of claims, or missed unsolicited communications as reliable proxies for fraud.\n\nHow many terminated enrollees have made a health care claim or requested reinstatement.\n\nWhether they are participating in a second phase of these terminations that is currently underway.\n\nSenator Hirono has long advocated for affordable, accessible, and equitable healthcare. In March, she led her colleagues in demanding immediate action by Health and Human Services to protect Americans\u2019 uninterrupted access to comprehensive family planning and services under Title X. In November, she pressed U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on the Administration\u2019s worsening affordability crisis, advocating on behalf of the 24 million Americans who would lose their ACA coverage under the Big Ugly Bill.\n\nIn addition to Hirono, Wyden, and Sanders, the letter was signed by U.S. Senators Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD), Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Andy Kim (D-NJ), Ed Markey (D-MA), Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA).\n\nThe full text of the letter is available below. The letters were sent to Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, AmeriHealth Caritas, Centene, Elevance, Florida Blue, Health Care Service Corporation, Imperial Insurance Companies, Oscar Health, and Molina Healthcare. Click here to see the full letter, sent individually to each respective executive.\n\nDear [Chief Executive],\n\nWe write to express serious concerns that [Insurer] worked with the Trump administration to kick qualified enrollees off their health plans without sufficient notice or compliance with consumer protections. We request responses to the questions below in order to better understand these serious threats to enrollees\u2019 health and finances, and to understand why [Insurer] chose to accept and act on baseless allegations of fraud from the Trump administration.\n\nOn September 22, 2026, the Trump administration announced that they, in coordination with [Insurer] and other issuers across the market, terminated Affordable Care Act (ACA) coverage for 760,000 enrollees. Republicans are weaponizing fraud falsehoods in order to undercut the ACA Marketplace and kick even more Americans off their health care. This year, nearly 3 million people have lost coverage while millions more are paying sky-high premiums and higher deductibles for insurance that covers less. Aligning with Republicans and their so-called \u201cwar on fraud,\u201d insurance companies chose to participate in a collaborative effort with the Trump administration to inject yet more chaos and damage into the ACA Marketplace.\n\nAccording to reports, these coverage terminations took place outside of the established process and regulations that govern mid-year eligibility determinations, and enrollees were identified as being subject to coverage termination based on metrics such as whether their projected income made them eligible for tax credits that cover the full premium of their plan, and whether they sought care during the 2026 plan year. We understand that this represented the first phase of this work, with a second phase already underway.\n\nAs you know, there is no credible research or evidence in support of the longstanding Republican conspiracy theory that zero-dollar premium plans and zero-claims enrollment are reliable proxies for fraud. Zero-dollar premium plans exist in private Medicare plans, and zero-claims enrollees are common across private insurance markets and across types of insurance. Claims to the contrary are based on discredited research generated by a right-wing think tank. However, these facts have not stopped the Trump administration and Republicans in Congress from parroting these falsehoods to justify taking coverage away from an estimated 15 million people over the next decade. Actors from across the health care system, including a coalition funded primarily by the insurance industry, have weighed in over time to rebut these falsehoods directly.\n\nThe 760,000 mid-year coverage terminations that took place would not have been possible without the cooperation of insurance companies that have been quietly colluding with the Trump administration on matters related to these improper coverage terminations since at least June 2026. It is our understanding that the ten largest issuers by Federally Facilitated Marketplace (FFM) enrollment received, and voluntarily complied with, a Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) data request designed to terminate coverage for hundreds of thousands of enrollees. Issuers, including [Insurer], took specific steps to assist CMS in their efforts, including sending unsolicited communications to enrollees asking them to verify their Social Security numbers. Issuers provided CMS with lists of enrollees who did not receive or respond to this unsolicited outreach asking for personally identifiable information. Those enrollees were deemed presumptively fraudulent, so-called \u201cphantom enrollees\u201d and their coverage was terminated retrospectively, effective August 31, 2026. Issuers agreed to carry out this request from CMS even though it was not supported by subregulatory guidance until such guidance was quietly modified by CMS on October 1, 2026, over one month after the 760,000 coverage terminations had been carried out.\n\nThe responsiveness to this potentially unlawful request from CMS, and the willingness to immediately act and initiate enrollee outreach efforts when asked to do so, stands in stark contrast with decisions made by issuers last year to forgo outreach to enrollees prior to the 2026 Open Enrollment Period. Despite repeated requests from Democratic lawmakers to contact enrollees so they could prepare for the historic premium increases that were about to take place due to Republican cuts to the ACA, insurance companies almost universally declined to perform any additional direct enrollee outreach, citing the cost and complexity associated with doing so outside the issuer renewal notice process. Issuers also expressed concern about being put at a competitive disadvantage should their enrollees choose to shop for more affordable coverage in light of rising premiums.\n\nWe have many questions about the role of [Insurer] in this flawed process used to terminate coverage for 760,000 enrollees, and the judgment exercised by insurance companies that chose to cooperate with CMS officials without requesting clarification about the specific authorities being relied on to support this request or raising concerns to Congress on behalf of their customers, enrollees that your companies receive billions of dollars in premiums and taxpayer support each year to serve. Given [Insurer]\u2019s cooperation and collaboration with the Trump administration in this process over the past several months, and the lack of specific information that the Trump administration has provided publicly or to Congress about what actually took place, we request that you provide detailed, numbered responses to each of the following questions no later than November 6, 2026.\n\nFor each question below, please also state whether [Insurer] conveyed this information to CMS in connection with its response and provide any relevant correspondence.\n\nWhen was [Insurer] first contacted by CMS to evaluate their list of so-called \u2018unauthorized enrollments\u2019? Did CMS indicate that their intent was to terminate coverage for enrollees? Please provide copies of all correspondence and informational material [Insurer] received from CMS or explain why you cannot do so.\n\nThe process that [Insurer] was asked to carry out does not align with the customary mid-year eligibility redetermination process, the guidance that existed at the time in the CMS Federally Facilitated Exchange Enrollment Manual (FFE Manual), or the steps that must usually be taken for a consumer to resolve a data matching issue (DMI). In light of that fact, did CMS provide clarification about the intent of this request and what the information you provided would be used for?\n\nIf not, did [Insurer] request this clarification? Did CMS provide a legal basis for this request? Did [Insurer] ask for one?\n\nCMS announced in January that they disenrolled 250,000 people for \u201ca \u2018fraud\u2019 reason\u201d. Yes or no, did [Insurer] have any involvement or communication with CMS regarding those disenrollments?\n\nIf yes, how did that process differ from the one discussed throughout this letter?\n\nGiven the inaccurate research and misleading positions taken by the Trump administration and Republican members of Congress over a period of years related to so-called fraudulent ACA enrollees, including their reliance on conclusory statements and inaccurate findings from sources such as the Paragon Institute, how did [Insurer] assess the likelihood that the Trump administration would use the information you sent them to continue to weaponize their false fraud narrative in order to take insurance from eligible people?\n\nIs it the position of [Insurer] that these mid-year eligibility redeterminations and subsequent disenrollments were processed by CMS consistent with federal requirements that existed at the time the request was carried out?\n\nIf not, did anyone at [Insurer] raise this concern with CMS? If so, please provide a written record.\n\nCMS updated the FFE Manual on October 1, 2026 to reflect the process that took place in July, which did not exist in the FFE Manual at the time [Insurer] carried it out. Please explain why [Insurer] chose to carry out a process in July that was inconsistent and at times in conflict with the policies in the FFE Manual at the time.\n\nPlease explain how [Insurer] complied with the grace period for enrollees to resolve DMIs once they were identified.\n\nWas this process consistent with the process customarily used by issuers and Exchanges to resolve DMIs?\n\nPlease provide complete answers to each of the following questions and include in your response whether [Insurer] provided this information in writing to CMS as part of its response. Please attach any relevant correspondence to CMS.\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee with a zero-dollar net premium a proxy for fraud? Why or why not?\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee who has not generated a claim at this point in the 2026 plan year a reliable proxy for fraud? Why or why not?\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee with a DMI on their coverage application a reliable proxy for fraud? Why or why not?\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee not responding to unsolicited communication from their insurance company, whether sent by mail, phone, text, or email, a reliable proxy for fraud? Why or why not?\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee choosing a zero-dollar premium plan an abnormal occurrence or a proxy for fraud? Why or why not?\n\nWe understand that [Insurer] attempted to communicate with affected enrollees via at least two of the following: text, phone, email, and/or mail. Please provide templates or examples of the language used for each of the types of communication [Insurer] relied on, including what specifically was communicated to enrollees about what would happen if they failed to respond.\n\nHow many notices were sent by [Insurer] and what percentage of enrollees did not respond to this unsolicited mid-year communication sent by [Insurer]?\n\nWhat percentage of enrollees historically respond to [Insurer\u2019s] unsolicited mid-year communications related to other matters?\n\nWhich types of enrollee communication are more effective relative to others, and how do factors such as income and family size affect response rates? Please provide answers for each type of communication [Insurer] relied on to reach enrollees in order to carry out the request by CMS.\n\nYes or no, is an enrollee incurring zero claims in a given plan year an abnormal occurrence in the employer market?\n\nApproximately how many enrollees as percentage of [Insurer]\u2019s total enrollment traditionally generate zero claims in a given plan year?\n\nDid [Insurer] provide this information in writing to CMS as part of its response? If so, please provide any relevant correspondence.\n\nYes or no, is it a common practice for enrollees with employer-sponsored coverage who generate zero claims over the first half of a given plan year to have their names submitted to their employer for disenrollment?\n\nIf no, why did [Insurer] make the decision to collaborate with CMS in generating a similar list of ACA enrollees?\n\nYes or no, is it the position of [Insurer] that the methodology and process established and carried out by CMS represents a sound approach to populating an accurate unauthorized enrollment list that results in the termination of nearly every enrollee included on the list?\n\nThe ACA prohibits issuers from rescinding coverage unless an enrollee is found to have committed an act of fraud. Is it the position of [Insurer] that these coverage terminations were carried out consistent with federal requirements? If so, please cite the relevant federal requirements.\n\nIn an environment where families are reporting unprecedented challenges affording basic necessities such as groceries and gas, has [Insurer] conducted any analysis on the effect that Trump administration policies have had on plan selection in 2026? Specifically, have increasing affordability challenges contributed to a greater need for individuals and families to move from Silver coverage to lower-quality Bronze coverage that may result in reduced or zero-dollar net premiums after the application of premium tax credits?\n\nIf so, did [Insurer] provide this information to CMS as part of its response?\n\nIn an environment where families are reporting unprecedented challenges affording basic necessities such as groceries and gas, has [Insurer] conducted any analysis on the effect that Trump administration policies have had on the ability of families to see their doctor and generate claims?\n\nIf so, did [Insurer] provide this information in writing to CMS as part of its response? Please provide any relevant correspondence.\n\nCMS has asserted in its September 23, 2026 interim final rule that disenrolling so-called \u201cphantom enrollees\u201d who incur zero claims will reduce premiums for consumers. Does removing enrollees who generate zero claims in a given plan year have a positive or negative effect on premiums and insurance risk pools?\n\nIn 2025 Senate Democrats made repeated requests to insurance companies to notify their enrollees of historic premium increases prior to Open Enrollment. Insurance companies repeatedly cited the complexity and cost associated with initiating new types of mid-year contact with enrollees and delays in finalizing premiums as an explanation for why they were unable to comply with this request to provide any information to enrollees outside the normal issuer notice process. In contrast, enrollee communications were initiated within weeks, if not days, in response to this request from Republicans. Please explain this disparity.\n\nHow many total enrollees were included on the so-called \u201cunauthorized enrollment\u201d list [Insurer] returned to CMS? Please provide a total number as well as a breakdown by state and family size.\n\nHow many enrollees with zero-dollar net premiums after tax credits were included on the socalled \"unauthorized enrollment\u201d list [Insurer] returned to CMS? Please provide a total number as well as a breakdown by state and family size.\n\nHow many children (under age 18) were included in the so-called \"unauthorized enrollment\u201d list [Insurer] returned to CMS for disenrollment? Please provide a total number as well as a breakdown by state.\n\nDid CMS consider providing additional time to resolve DMIs for policies that included children enrolled as dependents?\n\nDid [Insurer] propose to CMS that they should provide additional time to resolve DMIs for policies that included children as dependents?\n\nIf disenrollments were processed at the household level, did a DMI for one individual in the household trigger disenrollments for all enrollees in the household?\n\nHas [Insurer] evaluated the effect that these disenrollments will have on potential risk adjustment payments, medical loss ratio calculations, or plan year 2027 premiums? Please quantify where applicable.\n\nWe understand that people who had their coverage terminated on August 31, 2026 have since generated claims and/or sought to reinstate their coverage, thereby disproving the assertion by CMS that these terminations consisted only of so-called \u2018phantom\u2019 or unauthorized enrollees.\n\nHave any of [Insurer]\u2019s terminated enrollees that were included on the so-called \u2018unauthorized enrollment\u2019 list provided to CMS generated claims since the list was submitted? If so, how many?\n\nHave any of [Insurer]\u2019s terminated enrollees requested reinstatement? If so, how many?\n\nHow long does it take to fully reinstate enrollees that are determined to have been improperly terminated and what specific steps must be taken by enrollees and [Insurer]?\n\nWill [Insurer] be providing full financial protection for these individuals and families from any balance bills they may receive as a result of being terminated from their coverage without cause?\n\nAre reinstated enrollees receiving retroactive coverage? If so, what is the retroactive date of coverage?\n\nWe understand the process and coverage terminations discussed in this letter reflect the first phase of this flawed and misguided effort, with a second phase currently underway. Is anyone at [Insurer] participating in the second phase of this work, or aware of future phases of similar work? If so, what is [Insurer]\u2019s understanding of the second phase and any subsequent phases?\n\nIs [Insurer] once again collaborating with or intending to collaborate with CMS in this next phase?\n\nHave the results of the first phase altered [Insurer]\u2019s approach to collaborating with CMS on this next phase? If so, how?\n\nYes or no - has [Insurer] signed, or does [Insurer] intend to sign, the \u201cIssuers Pledge to Combat Marketplace Fraud\u201d that CMS recently sent to issuers, or any similar pledge requesting among other things a commitment to support CMS's broader fraud prevention strategy?\n\nPlease submit complete written responses to Ian_Hunter@finance.senate.gov as soon as possible but no later than November 6, 2026.\n\n###", 1, "2026-11-09T13:36:59Z", "2026-11-09T13:37:55Z"]], "columns": ["url", "title", "date", "year", "month", "party", "chamber", "state", "member_name", "bioguide_id", "domain", "scraper", "source", "date_source", "text", "has_text", "collected_at", "updated_at"], "primary_keys": ["url"], "primary_key_values": ["https://www.hirono.senate.gov/news/press-releases/hirono-wyden-sanders-senate-democrats-call-out-insurance-company-collaboration-with-trump-administration-to-kick-thousands-of-americans-off-health-insurance"], "units": {}, "query_ms": 1.0230247862637043, "source": "dwillis/congress-press", "source_url": "https://github.com/dwillis/congress-press", "license": "MIT", "license_url": "https://github.com/dwillis/congress-press/blob/main/LICENSE"}