{"database": "press", "table": "releases", "rows": [["https://www.schiff.senate.gov/news/press-releases/news-schiff-joins-raskin-blumenthal-in-pressing-kirkland-ellis-for-details-of-125-million-trump-deal/", "NEWS: Schiff Joins Raskin, Blumenthal in Pressing Kirkland & Ellis for Details of $125 Million Trump \u201cDeal\u201d", "2026-10-16", "2026", "2026-10", "Democrat", "Senate", "CA", "Adam B. Schiff", "S001150", "www.schiff.senate.gov", "schiff", "https://www.schiff.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/", "scraper", "Lawmakers Reject Kirkland\u2019s Excuses for Stonewalling Investigation and Demand Immediate Compliance\n\nWashington, D.C. \u2014Today, U.S. Senator Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) joined Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.-08), Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Committee and Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), Ranking Member of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations to press Chairman of the law firm Kirkland & Ellis Jon Ballis on refusing to cooperate with the Committees\u2019 investigation into Kirkland\u2019s decision to provide President Trump with $125 million in free legal services that align with his political agenda \u2013 rejecting the firm\u2019s previous bogus legal justifications for doing so.\n\n\u201cTo date, Kirkland has not cooperated with our legitimate oversight requests. Your firm has failed to produce a single responsive document and has refused to meet with Congressional staff. Instead, Kirkland has devoted its time to compiling a laundry list of legally specious claims of privilege. Notwithstanding Kirkland\u2019s lack of cooperation, we will use every tool at our disposal to pursue this investigation\u2014in this Congress and the next,\u201d wrote the lawmakers.\n\nKirkland has failed to produce any written agreement memorializing its $125 million deal with the Trump Administration beyond President Trump\u2019s Truth Social posts. Absent a written agreement, Trump continues to be the sole arbiter of Kirkland\u2019s legal obligations under the deal. As the lawmakers point out, Kirkland\u2019s professional judgment is necessarily compromised when it is under constant threat of being deemed in violation of its personal agreement with the famously vindictive President.\n\nTo resist congressional oversight, Kirkland provided vague, contradictory and legally unsound privilege claims that are not supported by legal precedent. The lawmakers reject each of these sham claims in detail.\n\nRequests for client identities, hours worked and the value of services do not implicate attorney-client privilege.\n\nKirkland\u2019s attempt to extend executive privilege to dealings with Trump\u2019s personal lawyer, Boris Epshteyn, is unsupported by legal precedent.\n\nKirkland\u2019s claim of a settlement privilege is similarly flawed as they faced no executive order when it entered negotiations, and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) acknowledged in federal court that it engaged in informal information gathering, not an investigation.\n\nThe lawmakers are renewing their demands for records and answers concerning Kirkland\u2019s negotiations with the Administration, communications with the President\u2019s personal lawyer, Boris Epshteyn, free legal work for federal agencies, potential conflicts with existing clients and efforts to poach attorneys and clients from Paul Weiss while it faced Trump\u2019s retaliatory executive order. They also seek an itemized response to outstanding questions, a detailed log supporting any privilege claims and written confirmation that Kirkland is preserving relevant records, including encrypted or disappearing-message communications.\n\nThe inquiry continues an investigation Raskin and Blumenthal launched in April 2025 into Trump\u2019s coercion of major law firms and the deals firms struck to avoid retaliation. Joined by Schiff, they subsequently scrutinized firms\u2019 free legal work for the Commerce Department, sought records of Epshteyn\u2019s role in Kirkland\u2019s deal and pressed Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP over potential conflicts involving its work for Intel and the Commerce Department.\n\nThe full text of the letter can be found here and below.\n\nDear Mr. Ballis:\n\nWe write for the sixth time regarding Kirkland & Ellis LLP\u2019s (Kirkland) decision to preemptively surrender to President Donald Trump and enter into a legally dubious settlement agreement with the Trump Administration. We have repeatedly requested information and documents about Kirkland\u2019s conduct, including with respect to: (1) Kirkland\u2019s attempts to poach attorneys from a rival law firm that was being extorted by the Trump Administration; (2) Kirkland\u2019s contacts with President Trump\u2019s personal legal fixer, Boris Epshteyn; (3) Kirkland\u2019s commitment to perform $125 million in pro bono legal services that align with President Trump\u2019s political agenda; and, Kirkland\u2019s seemingly unlawful provision of legal services to the U.S. Department of Commerce.\n\nTo date, Kirkland has not cooperated with our legitimate oversight requests. Your firm has failed to produce a single responsive document and has refused to meet with congressional staff. Instead, Kirkland has devoted its time to compiling a laundry list of legally specious claims of privilege. Notwithstanding Kirkland\u2019s lack of cooperation, we will use every tool at our disposal to pursue this investigation\u2014in this Congress and the next.\n\nTo comprehensively rein in presidential abuses of power through legislative actions, Congress and the American people must learn the full circumstances and nature of Kirkland\u2019s indefensible submission to an out-of-control executive. Why did Kirkland enter into this agreement? What was promised and by whom? And how did the President\u2019s coercion work in practice? Against that backdrop, we address your counsel\u2019s latest response to our congressional staff, dated May 28, 2026, which raises a multitude of vague, contradictory, and legally unsound objections.\n\nI. Attorney-Client Privilege\n\nIn the May 28 response, Kirkland objects to responding to our requests for records concerning your pro bono engagements and the provision of other free legal services, contending that it would \u201creveal client confidences, privileged communications, and attorney work product.\u201d Relying on a Third Circuit decision, United States v. Liebman, you argue the privilege extends to our requests because the documents \u201cwould convey the substance of attorney-client communications.\u201d As an initial matter, in the context of a congressional investigation, Congress is not obligated to recognize common law privileges, has never formally done so, and no court has ever held to the contrary. But Kirkland\u2019s position is also plainly inaccurate. Although Kirkland fails to specify which of our requests implicate the attorney-client privilege, even a cursory examination of our requests makes it readily apparent that no such privilege is implicated.\n\nBy way of example, we previously requested a list of pro bono matters that Kirkland has undertaken for the U.S. government, non-governmental clients who have been offered pro bono services pursuant to Kirkland\u2019s agreement with President Trump, and a dollar value of the pro bono services rendered. We similarly requested a list of the federal agencies that Kirkland has performed work for, the number of hours spent working for those agencies, and the billable value of those hours.\n\nThese requests simply do not implicate any applicable privilege. As Kirkland should know\u2014because it is in the very case that you cited\u2014\u201cIt is well established that \u2018absent unusual circumstances the identity of the client does not come within the attorney-client privilege.\u2019\u201d As the Liebman case and others demonstrate, the attorney-client privilege does not apply to legal requests\u2014including our requests\u2014that \u201cmerely request[] the names of clients who paid fees.\u201d Nor does the attorney-client privilege prohibit disclosures quantifying the \u201camount of a fee,\u201d or \u201cgeneral information about the nature of the services performed.\u201d\n\nAccordingly, please comply with the oversight requests reflected in our prior letters\n\nno later than October 29, 2026, including, but not limited to, the following:\n\nApril 18, 2025, letter: A detailed description of all requests for pro bono services you have received from the White House or any executive branch agency since entering into an agreement with the White House, including the nature of such request, the identity of the individual requesting the services, and the services your firm has agreed to provide.\n\nSeptember 24, 2025, letter: A list of the number of hours that Kirkland has contributed to the Commerce Department or the U.S. Government to date.\n\nMarch 2, 2026, letter: A list of all federal agencies that Kirkland has performed work for, the number of hours spent working for those agencies, and the billable value of those hours.\n\nII. Executive Privilege\n\nIn Kirkland\u2019s May 28 response, you contend that Kirkland cannot respond to our requests because they \u201cseek documents related to negotiations conducted on behalf of the President,\u201d arguing, \u201cexecutive privilege requires an opportunity for the President to assess whether to assert privilege over any of the materials sought and to intervene as necessary.\u201d Once again, that is\n\nincorrect. In support of this radical expansion of the executive privilege, Kirkland relies entirely\n\non a statement issued by a minority of D.C. Circuit judges in denying a motion for rehearing en\n\nbanc. As you well know, that statement has no precedential value and provides no legal basis\n\nfor withholding documents that Congress has identified as critical to its legislative function.\n\nYour response also obscures the more fundamental issue with Kirkland\u2019s assertion\u2014the firm was primarily negotiating with someone outside the Trump Administration. It was dealing with Donald Trump\u2019s personal lawyer, Boris Epshteyn, whom Trump Administration officials have identified as leveraging his proximity to the President to orchestrate multiple \u201cpay-to-play\u201d schemes. No court has held that the presidential communications component of executive privilege extends to communications with private advisors. But Kirkland\u2019s assertion goes even beyond that farfetched claim, arguing that because someone might advise the President, all of Kirkland\u2019s communications with that advisor similarly implicate executive privilege. Kirkland\u2019s theory could functionally exempt any communication by drawing a line, however attenuated, to a President\u2019s advisor\u2014irrationally expanding a narrow privilege. Such a transformation is clearly unworkable, unsupported by any legal precedent, and raised either in error or in bad faith.\n\nThe same holds for our request for a list of Trump Administration officials that Kirkland communicated with involving these matters. This narrow request did not seek the disclosure of the content of the President\u2019s communications\u2014or for that matter, the disclosure of any government official\u2019s communications\u2014and cannot implicate any executive privilege. To be clear, Kirkland\u2019s communications with government officials would, almost entirely, not be subject to executive privilege. But here, our requests do not even implicate those communications.\n\nAccordingly, please comply with the oversight requests reflected in our prior letters no later than October 29, 2026, including, but not limited to, the following:\n\nMarch 2, 2026, letter: All communications from Kirkland, or its agents, with Boris Epshteyn or his agents or associates, including but not limited to, meetings records, phone calls, emails, text messages, or letters.\n\nMarch 2, 2026, letter: A list of all individuals or entities who corresponded with Kirkland, or any of its agents, to discuss an agreement with the Trump Administration, including the date(s) of any and all contacts.\n\nIII. Settlement Privilege\n\nIn Kirkland\u2019s May 28 response, you object to the production of communications among Kirkland, the Trump Administration, and Administration representatives that were \u201cmade for the purpose of negotiating a mutually acceptable settlement of the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission\u2019s (EEOC) inquiry and anticipated Executive Order.\u201d Kirkland argues that \u201c[a]ny communications made in furtherance of settlement are privileged.\u201d In support of that argument, Kirkland cites a Sixth Circuit case, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. Chiles Power Supply, Inc., for the broad proposition that \u201cconfidential settlement communications are a tradition in this country.\u201d To be clear, this is an overbroad, and likely inaccurate, representation of federal law. As other courts have recognized, the Goodyear Tire decision \u201chas not been widely followed.\u201d Indeed, as determined by a D.C. federal court, advocates for a federal settlement privilege have failed to \u201cdemonstrate a broad consensus in support of such a privilege.\u201d\n\nAs you undoubtedly know, the Federal Rules of Evidence governing settlement negotiations are rules of admissibility for federal courts, not privileges. Moreover, congressional investigations are simply not bound by the Federal Rules of Evidence that underlie Goodyear and related cases. Even if we recognized the federal settlement privilege\u2014which we emphatically do not\u2014the unpublished decision you cited in further support of your argument strongly weighs against the application of the privilege here. Specifically, in Baker v. Secretary, U.S. Department of Transportation, the Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit concluded that a district court was permitted to consider communications between an individual and a federal agency in the context of an employment dispute, observing the settlement privilege did not apply because \u201cno formal complaint had been filed.\u201d Similarly, Kirkland was not the subject of a formal complaint at the time it entered into \u201cnegotiations\u201d with the Trump Administration. Although you have previously referenced resolving an \u201cinvestigation\u201d by the EEOC, the EEOC admitted in federal court that the letter it sent to Kirkland and others \u201cconstituted informal information gathering and were not a component of any investigation.\u201d Nor was Kirkland subject to an executive order at the time it entered into its agreement or contract with the President. Kirkland has made no effort to explain why a \u201cnegotiation\u201d privilege should attach to its conversations with the Trump Administration about the resolution of a voluntary request and a nonexistent executive order.\n\nAccordingly, please comply with the oversight requests reflected in our prior letters no later than October 29, 2026, including, but not limited to, the following:\n\nApril 6, 2025, letter: Did you approach the Trump Administration regarding a preemptive settlement to avoid an executive order against Kirkland, or did they approach you? Please describe in detail the timeline of your engagement with the Trump Administration.\n\nApril 18, 2025, letter: All records referring or relating to any executive order threatened by President Trump against Kirkland and efforts by Kirkland to negotiate an agreement with President Trump, including but not limited to:\n\nAny communications regarding any threatened executive order or any proposed agreement;\n\nAny communications with any officials in the Trump Administration from March 1, 2025, to the present regarding any threatened executive order and any proposed agreement; and\n\nDraft records constituting or related to any proposed agreement between President Trump and Kirkland.\n\nDeliberative Process\n\nIn Kirkland\u2019s May 28 response, you cursorily argue that Kirkland cannot produce documents related to settlement negotiations because you are not \u201cat liberty to waive any deliberative process privilege that the Administration wishes to assert.\u201d In support of this contention, you summarily cite a district court decision, Matter of Nelson, but neglect to quote from the decision or make even the slightest effort to analogize the facts and reasoning to the present matter.\n\nSince Kirkland has failed to explain the case cited in your own communications, we will do so here. The deliberative process privilege is a \u201climited privilege in several different ways.\u201d First, the privilege \u201cbelongs only to the government.\u201d This means that \u201cprivate parties\u201d\u2014like Kirkland\u2014\u201ccan neither assert nor waive the privilege.\u201d Second, it applies \u201conly to that group of communications within the agency or department.\u201d Your communications plainly did not occur within any agency or department of the United States. Third, the privilege must be \u201clodged by the head of the department which has control over the matter,\u201d a requirement designed to \u201cinsure that the privilege remains a narrow privilege which is not indiscriminately invoked.\u201d Your attempt to assert the government\u2019s deliberative privilege process here as a private party is an \u201cindiscriminate\u201d invocation of the privilege. Fourth, there must be a \u201cspecification of precise and certain reasons for the need to preserve the confidentiality of the documents at issue.\u201d You have not provided such reasons explaining why communications effecting a shakedown by the President of the United States warrant protection. In sum, this government privilege is completely irrelevant and unavailable to you.\n\nAccordingly, please comply with the oversight requests reflected in our prior letters no later than October 29, 2026, including, but not limited to, the following:\n\nApril 6, 2025, letter: All records referring or relating to President Trump\u2019s March 14, 2025, Executive Order \u201cAddressing Risks from Paul Weiss,\u201d including but not limited to:\n\nAny communications regarding the March 14, 2025, Executive Order; and\n\nAny communications with any officials in the Trump Administration from March 14, 2025, to the present concerning law firms other than Kirkland.\n\nApril 18, 2025, letter: Please describe in detail the circumstances surrounding your April 11, 2025, agreement with President Trump.\n\nWho facilitated your April 11, 2025, agreement with President Trump?\n\nDid Kirkland representatives meet with President Trump or members of his Administration?\n\nIf so, describe in detail who participated in the meeting(s), when and where they took place, and what was discussed.\n\nDid you acknowledge any wrongdoing for representing causes President Trump finds objectionable?\n\nRules of Professional Conduct\n\nIn Kirkland\u2019s May 28 response, you cite the American Bar Association\u2019s (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct to justify withholding communications requested by the Committees, arguing that Kirkland \u201ctake[s] seriously our ethical obligations to our clients and [is] committed to representing them with the highest standards of professional responsibility.\u201d It is fair to question whether Kirkland\u2019s leadership consulted the ABA Rules before it agreed to enter into a personal agreement with the President of the United States to perform $125 million worth of legal services. Indeed, a plethora of ABA Rules would have counseled against entering into such an agreement. For instance, the ABA directs attorneys to act with \u201ccourage and foresight\u201d to \u201cshape the body of the law to the ever-changing relationships of society.\u201d The ABA further directs lawyers to exercise their professional judgment \u201cfree of compromising influences and loyalties,\u201d emphasizing, \u201cneither the lawyer\u2019s personal interests, the interests of other clients, nor the desires of third persons should be permitted to dilute the lawyer\u2019s loyalty to the client.\u201d Most relevant here, lawyers must be alert to and disregard third parties who seek to exert \u201cstrong economic, political, or social pressures upon the lawyers.\u201d Kirkland\u2019s abject failure to reject an unprecedented, extortionate attempt by the President to control the legal profession, an attempt that multiple other law firms successfully rejected and resisted, implicates numerous professional responsibilities of lawyers, and none more so than its duty not to subject the judgment of the firm, and the interests of its clients, to the whims of a highly volatile and vindictive President.\n\nCritically, Kirkland has failed to produce any written agreement between the Trump Administration and Kirkland beyond what is contained in the President\u2019s Truth Social posts. That leads us to believe that there is no other written agreement. Assuming that is the case, President Trump appears to be the sole arbiter of what is required by the putative \u201ccontract\u201d and what would constitute a violation of the professional rules. Under these circumstances, Kirkland\u2019s professional judgment is necessarily compromised as it must always consider the impetuous desires of President Trump\u2014a third party who wields enormous economic and political pressure over Kirkland\u2014as demonstrated by your decision to succumb to this extortionary agreement in the first place. This is borne out by your representation of the Department of Commerce\u2014a representation that was never announced as being part of the scope of the agreement\u2014as well as press reports that the President has a \u201cbroader understanding of the terms\u201d of the contract than what is publicly known, including requiring capitulating firms to represent him in a personal capacity.\n\nKirkland cites a D.C. Bar opinion to further justify its decision to withhold documents from Congress. Again, Kirkland does not appear to have thoroughly vetted the materials it cited. In that very opinion, the D.C. Bar determined an attorney had not violated his ethical obligations by producing documents containing client confidences and secrets to Congress. To be clear, we have not requested materials containing client confidences or secrets, but even if we had, the D.C. Bar\u2019s opinion confirms that the D.C. Rules of Professional Conduct do not prohibit attorneys from complying with congressional oversight requests.\n\nThe D.C. Bar\u2019s reasoning for reaching its conclusion is instructive. Because Kirkland apparently has failed once again to thoroughly explain the opinion it cites, we offer an explanation of the relevant principles here. In determining that an attorney could disclose client confidences in response to a congressional request, the D.C. Bar relied on Supreme Court precedent holding that \u201ca contempt of Congress cannot be cured by the lawyer\u2019s later compliance with the subpoena,\u201d as well as the Supreme Court\u2019s holding that \u201cwhen a witness refuses to answer a question in a mistaken, good faith belief that it would violate his rights to be compelled to answer, his mistake of law will be no defense at a trial on the criminal contempt charge.\u201d Kirkland should be mindful of these precedents as it carefully considers its obligations in responding to requests from Congress.\n\nAccordingly, please comply with the oversight requests reflected in our prior letters\n\nno later than October 29, 2026, including, but not limited to, the following:\n\nApril 6, 2025, letter: Did members of your firm have contact with known Paul, Weiss clients about securing new or additional business from those clients from March 14, 2025, to March 20, 2025?\n\nIf so, which members of your firm and which known Paul, Weiss clients?\n\nIf so, please describe the nature of those conversations, including who initiated them, whether members of your firm made an effort to secure new or additional business in light of the executive order entered against Paul, Weiss, and any subsequent action taken in light of these conversations.\n\nIf so, please detail the extent to which you or other Kirkland attorneys sought or received any ethical guidance surrounding seeking new or additional business from clients of a firm facing an unconstitutional executive order, including from any state, federal, or other bar association.\n\nApril 18, 2025, letter: What were the specific terms of the deal Kirkland agreed to with President Trump?\n\nDoes President Trump\u2019s April 11, 2025, social media statement accurately reflect the terms of your deal?\n\nPlease detail all client relationships Kirkland has chosen to end from April 11, 2025, to the present.\n\nSeptember 24, 2025, letter: Explain whether Kirkland notified clients adverse to the Administration of Kirkland\u2019s work for the U.S. Government.\n\nMarch 2, 2026, letter: All agreements made with the Trump Administration, including but not limited to, settlement records, client retainer letters, conflict disclosures, and any communications informing such agreements.\n\nVI. Conclusion\n\nThus far, Kirkland has failed to cooperate with our investigation by refusing to provide relevant documents, refusing to meet with congressional investigators, and making baseless claims of privilege that do not withstand scrutiny. As illustrated above, the cases Kirkland cites in its defense provide no basis for withholding documents from legitimate congressional oversight. Nor has Kirkland made any meaningful effort to address the questions we have Posed. Vague assertions of privilege and ethereal references to purported legal constraints are not a substitute for identifying the specific basis on which Kirkland contends that particular documents or categories of information may be withheld. We therefore invite you to immediately revisit Kirkland\u2019s willingness to comply with our inquiries.\n\nPlease provide all records identified above by October 29, 2026. For other requests not outlined above, Kirkland should submit an itemized response to each of the questions raised in our letters dated April 6, April 18, and September 24, 2025, as well as March 2, 2026. To the extent that Kirkland objects to responding to any specific question posed, please expressly identify the question, state each concrete ground for the objection, and provide the legal authority supporting your position. Any claim of privilege must be accompanied by a detailed privilege log.\n\nWe expect your firm to preserve all documents and communications relating to the matters described in this letter. This preservation obligation includes but is not limited to: emails; text messages; messages sent via applications such as Signal, WhatsApp, X, Truth Social, or other encrypted platforms; handwritten notes; draft documents; calendar entries; and call logs.\n\nPlease confirm in writing by October 29, 2026, that you have taken all necessary steps to\n\ncomply with this preservation requirement. If you, or agents acting on Kirkland\u2019s behalf, have\n\nused ephemeral messaging applications or similar technology to communicate with Trump\n\nAdministration officials, or anyone purporting to act on the Administration\u2019s behalf, including,\n\nbut not limited to, Boris Epshteyn, please include that information in your written confirmation.\n\nThank you for your prompt attention to this profoundly important matter.\n\n###", 1, "2026-10-21T09:51:56Z", "2026-10-21T09:53:11Z"]], "columns": ["url", "title", "date", "year", "month", "party", "chamber", "state", "member_name", "bioguide_id", "domain", "scraper", "source", "date_source", "text", "has_text", "collected_at", "updated_at"], "primary_keys": ["url"], "primary_key_values": ["https://www.schiff.senate.gov/news/press-releases/news-schiff-joins-raskin-blumenthal-in-pressing-kirkland-ellis-for-details-of-125-million-trump-deal/"], "units": {}, "query_ms": 0.7552108727395535, "source": "dwillis/congress-press", "source_url": "https://github.com/dwillis/congress-press", "license": "MIT", "license_url": "https://github.com/dwillis/congress-press/blob/main/LICENSE"}