home / press / releases

Menu
  • Search all tables

releases: https://www.heinrich.senate.gov/newsroom/in-the-news/forbes-new-senate-permitting-bill-delivers-stronger-consumer-protections

One row per release. Full-text search runs over title + body text.

Data license: MIT · Data source: dwillis/congress-press

This data as json

url title date year month party chamber state member_name bioguide_id domain scraper source date_source text has_text collected_at updated_at
https://www.heinrich.senate.gov/newsroom/in-the-news/forbes-new-senate-permitting-bill-delivers-stronger-consumer-protections Forbes: New Senate Permitting Bill Delivers Stronger Consumer Protections 2026-10-05 2026 2026-10 Democrat Senate NM Martin Heinrich H001046 www.heinrich.senate.gov heinrich https://www.heinrich.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases scraper Congress is advancing a new permitting bill that pairs tougher cost protections and sharper litigation limits with a major expansion of federal transmission authority — a shift that directly answers the objections that stalled reform in 2024. Senators Mike Lee, Shelley Moore Capito, Martin Heinrich and Sheldon Whitehouse introduced the 417-page Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 last week, setting up a debate over how far federal power should reach and how much customers should pay as transmission projects move forward. It can be useful to compare the bill to its 2024 predecessor. Senators Joe Manchin and John Barrasso introduced the earlier Energy Permitting Reform Act in July 2024, but it never reached a floor vote. There were four main concerns with that legislation: how the bill would allocate the cost of new power lines, how it defined reliability, how far it would extend federal authority and how little it would do about litigation. Comparing the two bills on those questions shows where the new proposal has improved and where concerns remain. For critics who argued that conservatives should wait for a stronger negotiating position in the next Congress, the new text offers substantial evidence that waiting was worthwhile. Customers Gain Stronger Cost Protections One of the more consequential changes would require a closer relationship between what customers pay for a transmission line and what they receive from it. The 2024 bill instructed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees the interstate electric grid, to allocate costs “in accordance with the cost-causation principle,” meaning customers pay the costs attributable to serving them. Only customers receiving “no benefit, or benefits that are trivial in relation to the costs sought to be allocated” would have been explicitly protected from rate increases to cover those costs. A customer whose benefits exceeded that threshold could still have been charged far more than those benefits were worth to them. The new bill would require that costs be allocated “in accordance with the cost-causation principle and at least roughly commensurate with the benefits.” What a customer paid would therefore have to bear a reasonable relationship to what the customer received. The same cost-allocation standard would cover qualifying transmission projects whether they receive state or FERC siting approval. The language comes from the 2009 federal appeals court decision Illinois Commerce Commission v. FERC, and FERC included it in its 2024 transmission rule, Order No. 1920. The 2024 bill invoked cost causation without expressly stating a proportionality requirement. The new bill makes that safeguard explicit. The protection for customers receiving trivial benefits would remain, now supplemented by a proportionality requirement. The bill also specifies that nothing in it “shall prevent a transmitting utility from recovering such costs through voluntary agreement with its customers.” Such agreements could be reasonable where a utility and a large customer negotiate on equal terms. A Narrower Reliability Definition The new bill would also remove language that could have allowed renewable connections to qualify too readily as reliability improvements. The 2024 proposal counted “improved reliability” as a benefit that could justify charging customers for a transmission line. A project could qualify under any one of four tests, one of which included “any other similar material improvement, including a reduction in correlated outage risk, such as achieved through increased geographic or resource diversification.” Wind and solar farms spread across a large area could plausibly satisfy that description. A line built mainly to connect those projects could then have been labeled a reliability improvement, with costs allocated to customers who received no other benefit. The same test in the 2026 bill ends at “any other similar material improvement, including a reduction in correlated outage risk.” The phrase “geographic or resource diversification” is absent from the definition. Projects would still need to meet only one of the four tests, and the bill would still ask whether, “on balance,” reliability “is improved in a material manner that benefits customers.” The recognized benefits would remain much the same, from relieving grid congestion to improving access to cheaper power, but the revision would remove the specific language that invited treating diversification as evidence of greater reliability. Cooperatives Gain An Exemption As Federal Authority Grows In November 2024, Jim Matheson of the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association and Scott Corwin of the American Public Power Association (APPA) wrote to Manchin and Barrasso. They warned that the bill “establishes a one-size-fits-all, top-down approach by expanding the jurisdiction of FERC over co-ops and public power in an unprecedented fashion,” with public power referring to city- and state-owned utilities. Duke Energy and Southern Company also raised concerns about federal control of transmission planning. The 2026 proposal would create an “exempt transmitting utility” category covering state and local government utilities, plus electric cooperatives selling less than 4 million megawatt-hours a year. These utilities would remain outside the bill’s new transmission planning requirements unless they opted in. The ERCOT grid in Texas would also remain excluded, as it was under the 2024 proposal. FERC’s permitting authority would expand, however. Under current law, the agency can approve a transmission line over a state’s objection only within a corridor designated by the Energy Department. This power is known as backstop siting authority. The 2024 bill would have allowed FERC to approve qualifying transmission lines outside those designated corridors. It would also have allowed FERC to intervene if a state failed to act within one year after receiving an application. The new proposal would retain both changes and extend federal authority further. The 2026 bill gives qualifying transmission projects a more certain route to federal approval by reducing FERC’s discretion to withhold a permit. Whereas the 2024 bill would have allowed FERC to issue a permit once the legal requirements were met, the new text says it “shall” issue to permit, following at least 45 days of public comment. FERC would still need a statutory basis to override state siting authority, such as a denial, a year of inaction, or conditions that made the project economically infeasible. States could also refer a utility to FERC for an investigation of its local transmission planning. Local lines are built within a single utility’s territory and paid for entirely by its customers. If FERC were to find that the utility had built inefficiently, it could reduce the utility’s allowed profit and remove the presumption that its spending was reasonable. It could also impose fines of up to $5 million per facility, payable to the state that raised the complaint. That investigation provision is intended to protect customers from poorly scrutinized local spending. It would also give FERC new authority over planning decisions previously left to states and utilities, extending federal control in the direction Duke and Southern opposed. Giving FERC more power to approve transmission lines over state objections would make the bill’s consumer protections especially important. Supporters of expanding FERC’s permitting authority argue that state vetoes can block needed transmission lines between regions. But if federal approval allowed a project to proceed, customers would still need protection against being charged more than the benefits to them justify. The new bill’s requirements for costs to be roughly proportional to benefits make the expansion of federal authority more defensible. How The New Bill Addresses 2024 Concerns The comparison below summarizes how the new text addresses earlier objections. 2024 Objection 2024 Bill Text 2026 Bill Text Verdict Who pays for new lines Costs divided “in accordance with the cost-causation principle.” Floor only for customers receiving “no benefit, or benefits that are trivial” relative to the costs. Same floor, plus costs must be “at least roughly commensurate with the benefits.” Fixed Reliability definition One test included “a reduction in correlated outage risk, such as achieved through increased geographic or resource diversification.” The same test ends at “a reduction in correlated outage risk.” Fixed Federal control over cooperatives FERC planning and cost rules reach cooperatives and public power; only is Texas excluded. An exemption for state and local utilities and cooperatives under 4 million megawatt-hours; Texas still excluded (sec. 225(a)). Partly fixed FERC permitting power Corridor requirement removed. One-year clock runs from state filing. FERC “may” issue a permit. FERC “shall” issue a permit for qualifying lines after at least 45 days of public comment. New state-triggered investigations of local planning. Broader still Inflation Reduction Act subsidies Not addressed. Not addressed. But the 2025 budget law separately ended most wind and solar tax credits. Largely addressed separately Pipelines Transmission only. State water quality review of pipelines and power lines is limited to the project’s direct discharge. Partly fixed Environmental lawsuits 150-day filing deadline; no limits on who can sue or what courts can order. 150-day deadline, “direct harm” standing, comment requirement, and limits on court orders stopping projects, with an exception for likely violations of other federal law. Substantially fixed Source: S. 4753 (118th Congress), reported text; Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, Senate draft released Sept. 30, 2026. Litigation Limits Give Projects More Certainty The litigation provisions in the new permitting bill would go substantially further than the 2024 proposal. The Manchin-Barrasso bill did little to address the National Environmental Policy Act, the 1970 law requiring environmental review of federal decisions. Its 150-day filing deadline alone would offer little protection against delays caused by litigious groups. The new bill would retain that deadline but also narrow who has standing—the legal right to sue. A plaintiff would have to demonstrate “an actual or imminent injury in fact amounting to a direct harm.” Where an agency had taken public comments, the plaintiff would also need to have submitted one detailed enough “to put the applicable Federal agency on notice of the particular issue” later challenged in court. The bill would sharply limit remedies as well. If a court found a violation, “the only remedy the court may order” would be to return the decision to the agency “without vacatur or issuance of an injunction.” Vacatur means canceling the permit; an injunction could halt the project. The agency would have up to 180 days to correct its work while the project continued. Importantly, a court could still pause a project for a likely violation of another federal law. The environmental review title in the new legislation still leaves unresolved when an agency’s work should count as finished. Even so, if a lawsuit could no longer stop construction under the environmental review law, it would lose much of its value as a delay tactic. The new bill would also limit state water-quality reviews of interstate natural gas pipelines, addressing a gap in the 2024 proposal. Under its Clean Water Act provisions, states reviewing water-quality certifications for interstate natural gas pipelines and power lines could consider only a project’s “direct point source discharge,” or what flows directly into a waterway. They could no longer assess the project as a whole through that certification. A state denying certification would therefore have to show, by clear and convincing evidence, that the project could not be approved even with reasonable safeguards. In 2024, critics worried that easier transmission siting would channel more Inflation Reduction Act funding into intermittent generation. The 2025 budget law, however, ended production and investment tax credits for wind and solar facilities beginning construction after July 4, 2026, except for facilities entering service by the end of 2027. Easier transmission approval under the new bill would therefore have less scope to expand those subsidies. Data Centers Would Bear Their Own Costs The section titled “Ratepayer protection” of the new legislation addresses data centers, an issue outside the scope of the 2024 debate. It would require FERC to revise its 1994 transmission pricing policy so that data centers paid their share of existing grid costs as well as the additional costs of expanding the grid to serve them. A separate provision would prevent utilities from shifting any incremental costs of serving a data center of at least 20 megawatts to other customers. The data center would have to provide financial guarantees before the utility builds or upgrades facilities, and would remain responsible for unpaid costs even if it stopped using the utility’s service. States could charge those data centers more than the cost of serving them and rebate the surplus to other ratepayers. They could also use competitive bidding to determine which projects received service first. These provisions would limit cross-subsidies, in which one group of customers pays for another’s service. Their effectiveness will depend in part on estimates made “at or around the time that the covered load becomes operational.” Whether those estimates and the 20-megawatt threshold would provide adequate protection as state regulators set rates remains uncertain. Still, requiring data centers to bear the additional costs they create is nevertheless a sound starting point. Congress Still Has To Deliver A Law Based on the objections raised in 2024, waiting for a better permitting bill appears to have produced a number of benefits. Customers would gain a proportionality standard, and the reliability definition would lose its diversification clause. Cooperatives would receive an exemption, while litigation reform would go well beyond the earlier filing deadline. FERC would also gain permitting authority beyond what either current law or the 2024 bill provides. That expansion remains a concern, but the stronger cost standard would make it more defensible. Critics opposed rushing the 2024 bill through a lame-duck session. The new proposal arrives only weeks before an election and will face a lame duck of its own. As negotiations proceed, Congress should preserve the stronger consumer protections and litigation reforms. Whether waiting ultimately pays off will depend on whether those improvements become law. 1 2026-10-23T09:47:56Z 2026-10-23T09:49:00Z
Powered by Datasette · Queries took 0.805ms · Data license: MIT · Data source: dwillis/congress-press