home / press / releases

Menu
  • Search all tables

releases: https://www.murphy.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/murphy-details-codel-to-saudi-arabia-qatar-to-reporters-experts-foreign-dignitaries

One row per release. Full-text search runs over title + body text.

Data license: MIT · Data source: dwillis/congress-press

This data as json

url title date year month party chamber state member_name bioguide_id domain scraper source date_source text has_text collected_at updated_at
https://www.murphy.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/murphy-details-codel-to-saudi-arabia-qatar-to-reporters-experts-foreign-dignitaries Murphy Details CODEL to Saudi Arabia, Qatar to Reporters, Experts, Foreign Dignitaries 2026-10-29 2026 2026-10 Democrat Senate CT Christopher Murphy M001169 www.murphy.senate.gov chrismurphy https://www.murphy.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases scraper WASHINGTON, D.C.—U.S. Senator Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) on Wednesday joined The Atlantic’s Missy Ryan at the Middle East Institute for an in-depth conversation on his Congressional Delegation (CODEL) trip earlier this month to Riyadh, Saudi Arabia and Doha, Qatar. “I think we are seeing the president ready another devastating military campaign after the election, just as illegal as the first iteration was at a time where Americans are fed up with this war. I was the second member of the Senate to visit the region since the war began. I think it was incredibly valuable, not just to get a sense of how rattled the entire region is, but to really see firsthand, as I'm sure we'll discuss, a cover-up that is underway—a dizzying and coordinated attempt to try to hide from the American people and from Congress the costs and the consequences of this war. It looked like nothing I've ever seen in my 20 years in the United States Congress,” said Murphy. As the first Democratic Senator to visit the Gulf since the Iran war began, Murphy offered his takeaways from meetings with regional partners, including Qatari Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, and laid out his vision for what role Democrats in Congress should play in foreign policy after the midterm elections. Murphy forecasted a major spending fight in Congress to end the Iran war if Democrats take back the majority: “We become an illegitimate body, especially with respect to our foreign policy powers, if we do not use our spending power to end the war. The President has ignored the Constitution and ignored us. He has gone to war repeatedly in the Middle East, illegally, without congressional authorization. The natural consequence of that should be for the Congress to deny funding for the war if you are not prepared to come to us and get authorization. So I imagine what will happen is that there will be a continuing resolution after the election, and we'll push off the budget until January or February of next year. And then if Democrats are in charge, we will essentially say we want to fund the Department of Defense, but we are not going to fund the Department of Defense if it's funding this war. And so there will have to be some provision in the bill that denies any funding to be used for the continuation of a war against Iran that's making us less safe and costing billions to American citizens… And I can't even guarantee you that every Democrat would be united in that fight, because there are still Democrats that are hesitant about using the spending power, but I think it's our—I think it's our sacred responsibility as a co-equal branch to use the spending power to end the war. And that will be a discussion that will happen immediately, likely, in the first three months of next year.” He emphasized that the American people are begging Congress to end this war: “That would be a very popular position in the American public. And of course, it would be the mandate that we were given. If we win the House and the Senate, it is because people believe that by electing Democrats, they are going to end the war. So we would—we would have to use our power in that way.” Murphy detailed how he was denied access to American military bases in the Gulf as part of Pete Hegseth’s broader cover-up: “I was not only denied access to Al Udeid, but I was also denied the ability to talk to any Department of Defense leaders, any military leaders in the region while I was there. We made a formal request. I followed up in person with Admiral Cooper. When I told him that I was even being denied access to a briefing, he was surprised and told me that he would go back and review that decision. But by the time I got there, apparently his request for a review of that decision was of no avail… The State Department did support our visit. They did allow me to see the damage that had been done to the embassy in Riyadh. So it is an important contrast between the State Department, which is supporting our right of oversight, and the Department of Defense, which is engaged in the cover-up.” Murphy sounded the alarm on the damage to US military bases in the Gulf caused by Trump’s war: “I talked to enough people while I was on the ground there to understand the reality that our base in Bahrain is obliterated. It is not usable. And our base in Qatar is usable, but at a much lower capacity, and it is pretty clear that we still don't have the ability to protect any of our diplomats or our troops in the Middle East.” Murphy stressed that another military escalation with Iran will not re-open the Strait of Hormuz: “Well, it's of course clear that you're going to have to have some diplomatic agreement to reopen the Strait, but there's also no evidence that continued military action or threat of military action is increasing our leverage. In fact, it seems to be decreasing our leverage because it is empowering our liners inside Iran who are less willing to negotiate with us. And so, you know, query whether presence or absence of continued military operations against Iran is the thing that is most likely to get a deal. Thus far, there's no evidence that the presence of military operations is helping us to get a deal because we are today eight months exactly into this war and the Strait is still effectively closed.” Highlighting the ongoing risks to American troops in the region, Murphy advocated for a cautious approach to rebuilding regional infrastructure and a long-term reduction of US presence in the Gulf: “I have grave concern that we don’t have the ability to defend our personnel in the region right now. And obviously, Iran has made it very clear that if military operations restart and the United States starts bombing Iran at scale, that they are going to directly target Americans in the region. And I don't think anyone can give us any degree of confidence that we can protect our soldiers and our diplomats in the region. And so if the President restarts an active war with Iran, he does it with knowledge that it will likely end up in Americans being killed… What good is it to have a base in the region to protect American interests if within 24 hours of a hot war starting, it is wiped off the map? I mean, we would be criminally incompetent as stewards of taxpayer dollars if we were to rebuild bases that are blown up within hours of the next war starting. So clearly, we are going to have to have a smaller footprint in the region. And the limiting principle on the footprint that we rebuild will be what can we protect, because we clearly cannot protect the scope of our footprint today. And if we can't protect it, it is useless.” Murphy argued that Trump’s war has shifted the balance of power in the Middle East, handing Iran considerably more influence over its neighbors: “Unless there is regime change, which I do not think will occur, Iran emerges from this war fundamentally more powerful in the region. And that is a reality that all the Gulf nations have to deal with. And so it is likely that on the back end of this war, the implicit American security guarantee or arrangement that we have with Gulf countries is extinct. And that the only path forward is for those countries to be much more closely intertwined diplomatically with Iran and protect their interests.” Informed by what he’s been told by the Trump administration in closed briefings, Murphy issued a grave warning on Trump’s plan for the next stage of the Iran war: “In one of these briefings, we did get the chance to have a fairly detailed conversation about what the war plan would be if we restarted military operations. You've heard a preview that it would be a short-duration plan. I will just say this: their plan is insane. It will lead to devastating escalation and the likely destruction of our commitment to the rule of law… There's been open reporting as to what we may be planning and the civilian infrastructure that we may be targeting. They've been asked by the President to develop a plan. Whether they believe it will work or not, I do not know. But the plan that they have developed will lead, in my view, to a prolongation and an escalation of this war that will be devastating for our security interests.” Murphy stressed that Trump’s not only breaking domestic law in his execution of the Iran war: “I mean, this is the textbook illegal war. They are fighting a war without congressional authorization. They haven't sought congressional authorization. There hasn't been a hearing in the Foreign Relations Committee… But it is also clearly in contravention of international law and commitments that we have made to the rule of law to deliberately target civilians and to use the harm or potential harm of civilians as leverage in war. And it is also violative of commitments we have made to target political leadership at scale.” Murphy also commented on Trump’s indefensible decision to lift human rights restrictions on funding to the Egyptian dictatorship: “Yeah, I'm just heartbroken… a lot of people say, well, U.S. policy doesn't matter, right? Egypt's going to do what Egypt is going to do. Well, the last 10 days is evidence that that is not, in fact, true. The minute that that money was released, the crackdown began in an absolutely devastating way. It's not just that they were closed. Their employees were tortured, were locked up and tortured. To the extent that there was any glimmer left of political speech in Egypt, it is gone for one proximate reason: the United States government abandoned the people of Egypt and decided to remove all conditions on our funding. I am not saying that we were getting a lot from those conditions, but any hope of a true, meaningful political opposition rebirthing in Egypt has been shattered by this decision. But I understand why Trump wants to normalize the violent repression of free speech. If he’s opposing it in Egypt, it's easier for him to get away with it here.” A video of the full event is available here. A transcript of Murphy’s conversation is available below. Senator Chris Murphy: I'm eager to talk not just about my trip, but about this incredibly perilous moment. I think we are seeing the president ready another devastating military campaign after the election, just as illegal as the first iteration was at a time where Americans are fed up with this war. I was the second member of the Senate to visit the region since the war began. I think it was incredibly valuable, not just to get a sense of how rattled the entire region is, but to really see firsthand, as I'm sure we'll discuss, a cover-up that is underway—a dizzying and coordinated attempt to try to hide from the American people and from Congress the costs and the consequences of this war. It looked like nothing I've ever seen in my 20 years in the United States Congress. As we left, we were very closely monitoring what looked to be the beginnings of an assault on the airport, and as we were in the air, we got news that the airport had been hit and that people had been killed literally hours after we were gone. Within 24 hours of leaving the Riyadh airport it was shut down, and so we got to see firsthand just how chaotic this moment is, how the ripple effects just continue to exacerbate from our just unconscionable decision to begin a war in a region that we were not prepared for, nor were our allies. I hope that some of the stories and experience that I've been able to bring back are impactful in the discussion we're having now as to whether we're going to elect a Congress that continues to fund this war or whether we're going to make a decision to elect a United States Congress that will stand up for its war-making authorities, primarily through our funding power and work to bring this war to a rapid end. So it's great to be with you. Missy Ryan: Well, before we get to questions, I'd be remiss if I didn’t thank the Middle East Institute for having us today. And, Senator, it's an honor to be here with you today. Before we get into the substance of what you learned on this trip, I want to talk a little bit about some of the access that you had or did not have. You wrote, on social media, on Substack, maybe, about your inability to visit the [Al] Udeid Air Base in Qatar. Tell us about that. What did you – how did that go? How did the conversation with Admiral Brad Cooper, the CENTCOM commander, go around that? And for those of us in the audience who aren't familiar, how unusual is it that a sitting member of the U.S. Senate not be able to access a major military site? Murphy: Well, I mean, I got to the United States Congress in 2007 at the peak of the war in Iraq. And within months of being elected as a freshman member of the House of Representatives, I was on the ground in Baghdad, in the middle of the surge, being driven around an active conflict by General Odierno. Previous presidents believed, correctly, that it is our constitutional responsibility, obligation, and right as members of Congress to see war and conflict up close. How on earth do we make the decisions that we are empowered by the Constitution to make about whether we fund war if we can't see it? And so I really, to this day, have not heard a credible explanation from the administration as to why they have a policy of denying us access to bases when we are in the region. They have sort of sniffed around the edges of an argument about not having the resources or about protecting our safety, but none of it holds up to scrutiny. As I said, I was in Baghdad during the height of the 2007 surge. I was visiting four operating bases in Afghanistan during major military operations. They are – this is just very clearly a cover-up. They do not want the American people to understand the damage that's been done to these bases, and they don't want members of Congress to have the opportunity to directly talk to our military leadership and to our troops in the region, because that is where we often get the unvarnished truth about what is possible and what is not possible. So we were not only denied access – I was not only denied access to Al Udeid, but I was also denied the ability to talk to any Department of Defense leaders, any military leaders in the region while I was there. We made a formal request. I followed up in person with Admiral Cooper. When I told him that I was even being denied access to a briefing, he was surprised and told me that he would go back and review that decision. But by the time I got there, apparently his request for a review of that decision was of no avail. So I will give credit to the extent that credit should be given for doing their job to the State Department. The State Department did support our visit. They did allow me to see the damage that had been done to the embassy in Riyadh. So it is an important contrast between the State Department, which is supporting our right of oversight, and the Department of Defense, which is engaged in the cover-up. Ryan: Do the members of the Senate have any information, as we were discussing before, any imagery, satellite images or anything that would speak to the extent of the damage to the military facilities in Bahrain, in Saudi Arabia, in [Al] Udeid? You mentioned that you did visit the U.S. embassy in Riyadh and saw the extensive damage there. But what about the military facilities? What have you seen? Murphy: I have seen no imagery. I have been part of a number of classified briefings in which we were talking to our military leadership about the damage, but we were provided no physical or photographic evidence. I can't speak to whether the leadership of Armed Services or Defense Appropriation or their staff has seen photographic evidence, but we have discussed this in private briefings. But I talked to enough people while I was on the ground there to understand the reality that our base in Bahrain is obliterated. It is not usable. And our base in Qatar is usable, but at a much lower capacity, and it is pretty clear that we still don't have the ability to protect any of our diplomats or our troops in the Middle East. Ryan: And because the reconstruction of those bases is such a big topic of conversation, and how much that will cost and how long it will take, as a member of Defense Appropriations, what does it mean to not have that information in this stage of the game? Murphy: Well clearly, we have to make a decision soon as to whether we are going to rebuild. That was one of the hottest topics when I was in the region. Of course, Qatar and Saudi Arabia want us to keep a presence in the region, but what good is it to have a base in the region to protect American interests if within 24 hours of a hot war starting, it is wiped off the map? I mean, we would be criminally incompetent as stewards of taxpayer dollars if we were to rebuild bases that are blown up within hours of the next war starting. So clearly, we are going to have to have a smaller footprint in the region. And the limiting principle on the footprint that we rebuild will be what can we protect, because we clearly cannot protect the scope of our footprint today. And if we can't protect it, it is useless. Ryan: Yeah, so to that question, and then we're going to jump into what you learned from your conversations with regional leaders. Do you know whether – there's so much discussion of the potential for military action right before the midterms, right after the midterms – the U.S. military is ready to defend its facilities and, most importantly, its personnel if that occurs? Murphy: I have grave concern that we don’t have the ability to defend our personnel in the region right now. And obviously, Iran has made it very clear that if military operations restart and the United States starts bombing Iran at scale, that they are going to directly target Americans in the region. And I don't think anyone can give us any degree of confidence that we can protect our soldiers and our diplomats in the region. And so if the President restarts an active war with Iran, he does it with knowledge that it will likely end up in Americans being killed. Ryan: Let's talk a little bit about what you heard from the Saudi and the Qatari leaders. The big-picture question that I'd love to hear your conclusions about is how does the U.S. relationship with the Gulf and with those two very, very important countries in particular change post-Iran war? What specifically are they going to do now that they wouldn't have done in the absence of this war? What does it look like if the Republican Party is in the White House in 2028 or if it's not? What are the things that change? Murphy: Well, I think it's hard to answer that question now because the war is not over. In fact, we – it looks as if we're maybe just at halftime and that the President is prepared to restart the war and potentially use tactics that are even more provocative and dangerous and potentially violative of international law, which will mean the reprisals against the United States and our allies will be more significant. So I think it's hard to predict what the region looks like because we don't yet know what the rubble looks like. Ryan: Sure, but there are certain things that have changed. There are certain precedents that have been set in terms of Iranian willingness to close the Strait of Hormuz, to attack their oil facilities on a different scale. Did you get a sense from them about – regardless of how the war ends – how that will change how they operate vis-á-vis the United States? Murphy: Well, unless there is regime change, which I do not think will occur, Iran emerges from this war fundamentally more powerful in the region. And that is a reality that all the Gulf nations have to deal with. And so it is likely that on the back end of this war, the implicit American security guarantee or arrangement that we have with Gulf countries is extinct. And that the only path forward is for those countries to be much more closely intertwined diplomatically with Iran and protect their interests. Ryan: Did you get the sense of the contours of what that will look like in the future? Murphy: No, no, because we just don't know what the end state is. But obviously you are watching the Saudis right now talking directly to the Iranians, something that would have been unthinkable at this level just a few years ago. And yes, they are trying to deal with the exigent circumstances–the Houthis attacks on Saudi Arabia–but they are also laying the predicate for a longer-term dialogue that secures Gulf states' interests through direct talks with Iran rather than through their reliance on American security. And listen, if there is any razor-thin silver lining to this war, it may be that there will be greater direct communication between Iran and the Gulf countries, which I think for a long time should have been our primary goal rather than to act as a constant intermediary in those discussions. Ryan: Do you think that acts as sort of a balance for the region? Why should that be our goal? Murphy: Well, I don't think that there's any evidence that the United States simply feeding one side of the dispute in the region has led to more peace. As we have continued to sell weapons at a dizzying pace to the Saudis and to our Gulf countries since the Obama administration, all that has happened is the Iranians have increased the pace of their military investment, and we are now seeing their capacities that they have built up close. So I think it is in the United States' interest to have there be direct talks and direct relationships between Iran and the Gulf states and let them figure out a path forward to stability in the region because there is no evidence over the long course of America's modern involvement in the Middle East that our military presence in the region calms tensions. It just seems to exacerbate them. Ryan: I want to ask you a few Saudi Arabia-specific questions. Before we get into the substance questions, tell us about your decision to hold a meeting with MBS, something that you hadn't done before and you had been critical of his record on human rights and political freedom. Tell us about that. Murphy: I certainly have been one of the harshest critics of the U.S.-Saudi relationship and Saudi Arabia's behavior in the region. And frankly my criticism started long before MBS's four or five-year reign of inexplicably bizarre behavior. But listen, there is no way to protect U.S. interests in the Middle East without a relationship with Saudi Arabia, and things are different today than they were five to ten years ago. MBS's behavior in the region has become more stable and more reliable. He's not locking up prime ministers and members of his family in the same way that he was a decade ago, and the social opening in the country is real. I think it's been an indefensible trade, [more] social space for [less] political space, but I thought it was important for me to see it for myself. And then I also just thought that there needed to be some hard messages delivered, both in Saudi Arabia and in Qatar. Our foreign policy has been corrupted, and whether it's through pressure or just opportunism, the Gulf countries have cut these personal financial deals with the Trump family that I think jeopardizes their long-term relationship with the United States, and I wanted to say that directly to both Mohammed bin Salman and to the Amir, and to recommend to them that they at least refuse to get any more deeply financially intertwined with the Trump family, because I think that will fundamentally jeopardize their long-term relationship with the United States if they are perceived to be only interested in a relationship with one political family. Ryan: What was the response? Murphy: I mean, it wasn't what I hoped, but maybe it was what you should expect. Obviously, I was in the room with members of the State Department that were going to immediately report back what the Amir and what MBS said to me to the Trump administration and to members of the Trump family, so I did not expect that they were going to tell me that they had been bludgeoned into investing in Jared Kushner's hedge fund, or private equity firm. So, the Saudis defended their deals as good business deals that were legal and independent of their security relationship with the United States, and the Qataris told me that they had received guarantees that the plane would remain in the U.S. government's hands and would not ultimately be owned by the Trump family, so both countries defended their financial agreements. Ryan: Do they acknowledge a perception problem, at least in one half of the American political establishment? Murphy: They understand and acknowledge the perception and political problem, but they are being attacked on a regular basis by a neighbor, and so right now they have a short-term concern with maintaining a relationship with the administration such that this war doesn't get any more out of control. Ryan: So, the Trump administration and Trump himself has brought up, has hinted or kind of implied that there could be progress on a normalization deal with Saudi Arabia. What do you hear on Israel and Saudi Arabia? Murphy: Yeah, I spent about two hours with Mohammed bin Salman and we covered a number of topics, but we didn't go deep into the question of normalization, but I certainly, you know, had a long dinner with Prince Faisal and spent a lot of time with other members of the government. I mean, I don't think the bottom line has changed, that there will need to be demonstrable, real progress on Palestinian statehood, especially in the wake of Gaza, before Saudi Arabia enters into serious negotiations about normalization. You know, there's this narrative that people have that, oh, MBS doesn't really care about the Palestinians. I didn't come back with that view. I think in the wake of the Gaza nightmare, the Saudis are even more focused on making sure that if they were to agree to normalization, that there would be significant progress guaranteed as part of that deal for the Palestinians. Ryan: And what did you hear about the administration's reluctance to assist them in the current Yemen-Houthis campaign? Murphy: Well, I don't see reluctance. I mean, we're at war again. We are providing refueling support, we are providing significant intelligence support. Ryan: But we're not providing what the British and the French are. Murphy: Well, just because we're not providing what MBS wants doesn't mean we aren't at war. So this is another illegal war. It is not in our security interest to help the Saudis go back to war on the ground inside Yemen. I mean, when I was there, they said, you know, we're going to make quick progress on the ground, we're going to flip tribes hour by hour, and it could be a matter of days or weeks before we regain all the territory that we lost. You all know, predictably, what has happened: they have gained almost none of the territory back. In fact, the Houthis are still engaged in an offensive on Taiz. And it's just deepening the Houthis' resolve. It is causing more humanitarian misery and it acts as a means to ignore the actual real work that has to be done on the ground to achieve some political settlement that, whether we like it or not, is going to involve some Houthi ownership and participation in a future Yemeni government. Ryan: So we are only a few days from the midterm elections. Nobody knows what's going to happen in the Senate, certainly. If the House flips, as most polls suggest it will, what will oversight look like on the Iran war, you know, looking across both chambers? What's possible, really, given Article II powers and all that? Murphy: Listen, we become an illegitimate body, especially with respect to our foreign policy powers, if we do not use our spending power to end the war. The President has ignored the Constitution and ignored us. He has gone to war repeatedly in the Middle East, illegally, without congressional authorization. The natural consequence of that should be for the Congress to deny funding for the war if you are not prepared to come to us and get authorization. So I imagine what will happen is that there will be a continuing resolution after the election, and we'll push off the budget until January or February of next year. And then if Democrats are in charge, we will essentially say we want to fund the Department of Defense, but we are not going to fund the Department of Defense if it's funding this war. And so there will have to be some provision in the bill that denies any funding to be used for the continuation of a war against Iran that's making us less safe and costing billions to American citizens. That will be a fight, right? And I can't even guarantee you that every Democrat would be united in that fight, because there are still Democrats that are hesitant about using the spending power, but I think it's our—I think it's our sacred responsibility as a co-equal branch to use the spending power to end the war. And that will be a discussion that will happen immediately, likely, in the first three months of next year. Ryan: So you could say we're going to give you money to rebuild some of these bases to, you know, like, move or buy more air defense support, but not industrial-type operations? Is that possible? Murphy: There's no way that we can provide them funding to replenish missile stocks if those missile stocks are going to be used to continue the war in Iran. I'm interested in replenishing missile stocks if it's for the purpose of defending true United States interests. So yes, I think there's only one path to providing them funding for the Department of Defense. It is with an ironclad provision in that bill that says these weapons and these funds can't be used to continue the war in Iran. And that would be a very popular position in the American public. And of course, it would be the mandate that we were given. If we win the House and the Senate, it is because people believe that by electing Democrats, they are going to end the war. So we would—we would have to use our power in that way. Ryan: I've also heard Democrats say, though, we can't just walk away from the Strait of Hormuz. Like, you can't actually cede that to Iran. How do you deal with that? Murphy: Well, it's of course clear that you're going to have to have some diplomatic agreement to reopen the Strait, but there's also no evidence that continued military action or threat of military action is increasing our leverage. In fact, it seems to be decreasing our leverage because it is empowering hardliners inside Iran who are less willing to negotiate with us. And so, you know, query whether presence or absence of continued military operations against Iran is the thing that is most likely to get a deal. Thus far, there's no evidence that the presence of military operations is helping us to get a deal because we are today eight months exactly into this war and the Strait is still effectively closed. Ryan: In your conversations and the briefings that you've had with CENTCOM leadership and the military leadership and the intelligence officials that you have spoken with, do you get the sense that they agree with that position? You know, that bombing Iran isn't going to make its regime change more likely or the IRGC more likely to say, you know what, you're done? Murphy: So I've asked that exact question in these briefings and there is no candor allowed for our military leaders in these briefings. My sense is that they have an opinion as to whether the restart of military action will be helpful or hurtful in ultimately protecting our interests, but they do not share that opinion with us in closed briefings, which is different. I won't say that there's always been robust candor on when military leadership disagrees with political leadership, but there's been much more leeway, to be honest, in classified briefings, than there is here. In one of these briefings, we did get the chance to have a fairly detailed conversation about what the war plan would be if we restarted military operations. You've heard a preview that it would be a short-duration plan. I will just say this: their plan is insane. It will lead to devastating escalation and the likely destruction of our commitment to the rule of law. Ryan: Can you say more? Murphy: There's been open reporting as to what we may be planning and the civilian infrastructure that we may be targeting. They've been asked by the President to develop a plan. Whether they believe it will work or not, I do not know. But the plan that they have developed will lead, in my view, to a prolongation and an escalation of this war that will be devastating for our security interests. Ryan: Two more questions before we open it up. You mentioned the rule of law. Does that plan—do you know anything about the legal justification or sign-off or what the JAGs or the Office of Legal Counsel—anything on that front? Murphy: I mean, the law and the Constitution is meaningless to this administration. I mean, this is the textbook illegal war. They are fighting a war without congressional authorization. They haven't sought congressional authorization. There hasn't been a hearing in the Foreign Relations Committee. Every first-year law student could tell you that this war is illegal, and so clearly the lawyers have no impact. But it is also clearly in contravention of international law and commitments that we have made to the rule of law to deliberately target civilians and to use the harm or potential harm of civilians as leverage in war. And it is also violative of commitments we have made to target political leadership at scale. And so if those are part of any war plan, it will do grave damage to U.S. credibility in the long run, in addition to being wildly escalatory. Ryan: Last question before we open it up. And I'm speaking on an Egypt question, even though this is an event about the Gulf. I'd love for you to comment on the closure of Mada Masr and the detention of the publication’s editor. Murphy: Yeah, I'm just heartbroken about it. I wrote a long social media post on this yesterday, in part because I have long been a critic of our willingness to continue to fund the Egyptian government without any progress or commitments on political freedom in that country. And I was a critic of the Biden administration, as I am of the Trump administration. But a lot of people say, well, U.S. policy doesn't matter, right? Egypt's going to do what Egypt is going to do. Well, the last 10 days is evidence that that is not, in fact, true. The minute that that money was released, the crackdown began in an absolutely devastating way. It's not just that they were closed. Their employees were tortured, were locked up and tortured. To the extent that there was any glimmer left of political speech in Egypt, it is gone for one proximate reason: the United States government abandoned the people of Egypt and decided to remove all conditions on our funding. I am not saying that we were getting a lot from those conditions, but any hope of a true, meaningful political opposition rebirthing in Egypt has been shattered by this decision. But I understand why Trump wants to normalize the violent repression of free speech. If he’s opposing it in Egypt, it's easier for him to get away with it here. 1 2026-11-09T13:36:59Z 2026-11-09T13:37:55Z
Powered by Datasette · Queries took 1.592ms · Data license: MIT · Data source: dwillis/congress-press